| Año |
Receptor - Equipo |
Año |
Receptor - Equipo |
| 1996 |
Carlos Valderrama - Tampa Bay Mutiny |
1996 |
Roy Lassister - Tampa Bay Mutiny |
| 1997 |
Preki - Kansas City Wizards |
1997 |
Preki - Kansas City Wizards |
| 1998 |
Marco Etcheverry - D.C. United |
1998 |
Stern John - Columbus Crew |
| 1999 |
Jason Kreis - Dallas Burn |
1999 |
Jason Kreis - Dallas Burn |
| 2000 |
Tony Meola - Kansas City Wizards |
2000 |
Mamadou Diallo - Tampa Bay Mutiny |
| 2001 |
Alex Pineda Chacon - Miami Fusion |
2001 |
Alex Pineda Chacon - Miami Fusion |
| 2002 |
Carlos Ruiz - Los Angeles Galaxy |
2002 |
Taylor Twellman - New England Revolution |
| 2003 |
Preki - Kansas City Wizards |
2003 |
Taylor Twellman - New England Revolution / Carlos Ruiz - Los Angeles Galaxy |
| 2004 |
Amado Guevara - MetroStars |
2004 |
Pat Noonan - New England Revolution / Amado Guevara - MetroStars |
| 2005 |
Taylor Twellman-New England Revolution |
2005 |
Taylor Twellman - New England Revolution |